Artificially generated images are a new source of disinformation. Zambia doesn’t have a mobile phone factory – yet.

MARY ALEXANDER • 2 FEBRUARY 2024

A glossy image of workers assembling smartphones has been circulating on social media since November 2023 with the claim it’s a mobile phone factory in the central African country of Zambia.

Its captions include:

• Picture of students in a phone manufacturing factory in Zambia.
• The big factory of phone in Zambia.
• A phone’s factory in Zambia, Africa.
• A mobile phone factory in Zambia. Africa on its way to greatness.

But in the comments, several people say the image is AI-generated.

AI or artificial intelligence uses computer algorithms to perform some tasks otherwise done by people, like answering questions and writing code. One task it’s really good at is creating images from simple instructions.

The image and its claim can also be seen here, here, here and here.

But was it really snapped in a Zambian mobile phone factory, or is it artificial?

Outsmarting AI

There are a few signs that the image was made with AI.

The first is that it doesn’t look much like a real smartphone factory. Photos and videos of phone manufacturing show conveyor belts, robotic machinery and workers in protective gear – gloves and head coverings. None of these are in the image.

The almost identical pose of the workers, with their heads and hands in the same position at the same time, is oddly unnatural. They also seem to be making devices of many different sizes.

Then there’s the worker in the foreground’s gobbledegook name tag, which isn’t in any alphabet. AI image generators are known to struggle with text. And the edge of a large phone component in front of the worker is incomplete, appearing to merge into the table.

To make sure, we ran the pic through four AI image detectors.

Is it AI? concluded there was a 65% likelihood the image was AI-generated. The other three detectors were more decisive, with Illuminarty putting the probability at 85.5%, Content at Scale at 95% and Umm-Maybe at 96%.

Zambia and China’s ZTE to build smartphone plant in 2024

More than this, Zambia doesn’t have a mobile phone factory – yet.

At the November 2023 Africa Fintech Summit in Lusaka, the country’s capital, Zambian science and technology minister Felix Mutati announced plans for a new smartphone assembly plant to be built in partnership with China’s tech giant ZTE.

It’s expected to be completed in June 2024.

“Building the gadgets in the country will enable us to reduce the cost of smartphones in the country and hence foster inclusivity when it comes to connectivity,” Mutati said in his announcement.

This indicates that smartphones aren’t currently made in Zambia.

In 2009 a locally owned company, M-Tech Zambia, was set up to manufacture less sophisticated feature phones. But it reportedly struggled with stiff competition from cheaper imports from China. We’ve been unable to find any online mention of the company since 2011, despite repeated searches.

In any case, the inside of the M-Tech plant – as seen in a photo and a video shot in 2009 – looked nothing like the viral image.

The image doesn’t show a mobile phone factory in Zambia. It’s a computer algorithm’s output on what such a factory might look like.

* Some Facebook and Instagram users may have deleted their posts after Meta’s Third-Party Fact-Checking Program rated their claims as untrue.

Published by Africa Check on 5 February 2024